Composite vs Amalgam Fillings: Which Is Better for Your Tooth?

Most cavities today are filled with tooth-colored composite, but silver amalgam is still used. Here is how the two compare on looks, strength, cost and insurance.
A filling is the most common way to repair a tooth with a cavity. After the dentist removes the decay, the space has to be filled with a material that restores the tooth's shape and lets you chew normally. Today most offices use tooth-colored composite resin, but silver amalgam is still available and sometimes still recommended. Here is what you should know about both.
What Is a Composite Filling?
Composite is a mix of plastic resin and fine glass-like particles. It is placed in layers, shaped to match the tooth and hardened with a curing light. Because it bonds to the tooth and can be matched to your natural shade, composite fillings are hard to see, which is why they are often called white fillings.
Composite bonding to the tooth means the dentist can often remove less healthy tooth structure than with amalgam. The same material is also used to repair chips and close small gaps.
What Is an Amalgam Filling?
Amalgam is a blend of metals, including silver, tin, copper and mercury. It has been used for more than a century, is strong, and tolerates moisture during placement, which can matter for teeth far back in the mouth or for patients who have trouble keeping still. Amalgam is clearly visible as a dark silver patch.
The FDA considers amalgam safe for most adults and children over six, but since 2020 it has recommended that certain higher-risk groups avoid it where appropriate, including pregnant or nursing women, women planning a pregnancy, young children, and people with mercury allergy, kidney problems or certain neurological conditions. Intact amalgam fillings generally do not need to be removed just because they are amalgam.
How They Compare
- Appearance: composite matches the tooth; amalgam is silver and visible.
- Lifespan: amalgam often lasts 10 to 15 years or longer; composite often lasts around 5 to 10 years or more, depending on the size and location.
- Tooth preparation: composite usually needs less drilling because it bonds to the tooth.
- Placement: composite takes longer and needs a dry field; amalgam is quicker and more forgiving of moisture.
- Sensitivity: both can cause short-term sensitivity; composite sometimes causes more for a week or two.
- Cost: composite usually costs more, often in the low hundreds of dollars per filling, depending on size.
Does Insurance Cover White Fillings?
Many dental plans cover fillings, but some pay only the amalgam rate for back teeth and leave you to pay the difference for composite. This is called a "downgrade" or alternate benefit clause. Ask your dentist's office to check your plan before treatment, especially for molars. If you want to make the most of your benefits, our guide to dental insurance tips for families may help.
What About Other Materials?
For larger cavities, your dentist may suggest an inlay or onlay, a lab-made or milled ceramic piece that fits into or over part of the tooth. If a tooth is badly broken down, a crown may be the better long-term choice. Glass ionomer fillings are sometimes used near the gumline or in baby teeth because they release fluoride.
What Happens at a Filling Appointment
The dentist numbs the area, removes the decay, cleans the space and places the filling. Composite is built up in layers and hardened with a light; amalgam is packed in and carved. You will usually be done in under an hour. Your lip and cheek may stay numb for a few hours, so avoid hot drinks and chewing on that side until feeling returns. Mild sensitivity to cold or biting pressure for a few days is common. If your bite feels high, call the office for a quick adjustment.
Preventing the Next Cavity
Brush twice a day with fluoride toothpaste, clean between your teeth daily and limit sugary snacks and drinks between meals. Regular checkups catch small cavities while they are still easy to fill. Children can also benefit from sealants on their back teeth.
Need a filling or a checkup? Find general dentists on BizMox and compare offices near you.
Frequently Asked Questions
Comments (0)
Leave a Comment
You need to be signed in to leave a comment.
Sign in to comment

